In my conversations with people, I get asked a similar set of general questions: what is your speciality? How do you stay so skinny? What is your favorite thing to cook? What is your favorite restaurant in Seattle? A recent favorite is: Would you or would you not want to go on Top Chef?
I'm completely addicted to this show, which is sort of funny because we don't even have a functional tv, so the wine goddess and I watch week-old episodes that we download from the web on our 12 inch Mac PowerBook. I'm mesmerized from the first second to the last, albeit for those moments when Padma "I speak this slowly so the camera can linger on my cleavage" Lakshmi comes on the screen and then I'm fascinated, but for entirely different reasons.
I love this show because I'm intrigued by what chefs under intense stress and public scrutiny create when faced with extremely challenging tasks. On last week's episode, they were asked to come up with a small plate to impress 300 VIPs at a nonprofit function. They were told they'd have no help, limited funds and 2-3 hours of prep time. After an intense evening under these circumstances, they will then be ripped apart by famous chefs on national television. They will also be ripped apart, albeit hilariously, by bloggers (kudos to this blogger for saying what I never could by calling the chef contestant Melissa "bang-face" among other things).
I'll admit, some days I'd love to see how I would stack up and not just against Padma. This particular batch of chefs is less than impressive and I think I might just do okay, but in previous years I think I'd be somewhere in the middle. What I would do, unlike many of the contestants, is prepare myself. Perhaps this is my age speaking (most of the contestants are younger than I am) but really, it's not like they were whisked off in the middle of the night to join Top Chef. Once you are selected, I imagine you have time to mentally prepare yourself. This preparation could include memorizing a few signature dishes for each course of a tasting menu (including dessert, chefs! It just makes me laugh that some of them can turn out some really impressive dishes and then visibly pale in fear if they need to come up with a dessert). I would memorize dishes that are both simple enough to execute with confidence under pressure but have one or two elements of distinctive panache that would set you apart. A unique touch, an unusual use of spice, a deeply flavorful sauce; a set of dishes that give thought to color, composition, flavor and seasonality. I would only cook things that I had worked with before (unless forced). A competition is NO time to figure out how to get the meat out of a conch (and no, a mallet is not a good tool). An ostrich egg might be novel, but you'll look like the tool trying to crack it open if you have no experience doing so.
And then there are the egos. My, my. You take a large group of artistic, control-freaks that are used to running their own kitchens and throw them into a fishbowl with sharp knives, form them into small teams and make them compete under stressful conditions. It gets ugly.
"Typical chefs," says my jaded wine goddess. With years of working for ego maniacal hotheads that harass front of the house staff for sport under her belt, she feels entitled to her opinion. I always flinch when she says this; there's truth in her words and yet, I hate being painted with the same paintbrush when, for the most part, I try to keep my ego away from my kitchen. "What's that, honey?" Oh sorry, our kitchen.
There's all the difference in the world between confidence and bluster. You simply stop learning when you think you have all the answers. And besides, it's just so terribly unattractive in a person. It's food, people. You're not finding the cure for cancer.
It's easy to sit back in my chair, with my Mac television slash lap warmer and think I could do better than the contestants but at the end of the day, I'd never want to deal with the stress that they go through. I'm not sure I would hold up well under the lights and scrutiny. I can see myself beading up like a bad meringue, full of air and promise, with a lot of opportunity to weep and deflate. I give them a lot of credit for what they do. I wouldn't want to put myself through that, even if I think I could do better. At the end of the day, I don't think my ego could handle the failure if things went down the shitter.
Typical chef.




